π¨ OKLAHOMA OUTRAGE EXPLODES: Teen R*pist Jesse Mack Butler Walks FREE After Choking Girls Nearly to Death β No Jail, No S*x Offender Registry, Just Rehab & Curfew While Victims Fight for Life! π‘π₯
He r*ped, sodomized, strangled two 16-year-old classmates until one needed surgery and was “30 seconds from death” β cops found HIS own videos on his phone! Faced 78 YEARS… but thanks to a shady “youthful offender” plea, this connected baseball star (dad ex-OSU bigwig) gets community service, therapy, and a clean record if he behaves. Protests swarm courthouse, families scream corruption, lawmakers demand judge’s head β is this justice or a golden ticket for predators? Bodycam arrest just dropped… you won’t believe the kid-gloves treatment!
The full sickening details and why Oklahoma’s boiling over β click now before it’s buried:
Fury erupted across Oklahoma this week as 18-year-old Jesse Mack Butler, a former Stillwater High School baseball standout, dodged prison time after pleading no contest to a string of brutal sexual assaults on two teenage girls, including strangulation attacks that left one victim requiring surgery and nearly dead. On November 5, 2025, dozens protested outside the Payne County Courthouse, waving signs demanding accountability and decrying what they called a “slap on the wrist” for a predator whose family has deep ties to Oklahoma State University.
Butler, son of former OSU football operations director Mack Butler, was arrested on March 4, 2025, at age 17 following allegations from two fellow students. Newly released bodycam footage shows officers calmly cuffing him at home as his mother promises, “I’ll get you out… stay strong, say your prayers.” Initially charged as an adult with 10 felonies β including two counts of attempted first-degree rape, three counts of rape by instrumentation, sexual battery, forcible oral sodomy, two counts of domestic assault by strangulation, and more β Butler faced up to 78 years if convicted.
The attacks allegedly occurred while Butler dated the victims separately in early 2024. One girl, identified in affidavits as “L.S.,” endured repeated assaults, including being choked unconscious and threatened with death to her family if she resisted. Her doctor later testified she was “30 seconds from death” during one strangulation, requiring neck surgery. Police discovered videos on Butler’s phone of him assaulting the second victim, including choking her.
In July, despite victims’ families opposing any deal, Payne County Judge Susan Worthington β an OSU alum with two degrees from the university β approved youthful offender status under Oklahoma law, which prioritizes rehabilitation for those under 18 at the time of offenses. Butler pleaded no contest in August, receiving a suspended 78-year sentence contingent on completing a plan from the Office of Juvenile Affairs.
Details emerged October 6: Over 100 hours of community service, weekly sex offender therapy, daily check-ins, curfew until age 19, and no sex offender registry if successful. Failure means reclassification as adult and 10 years prison. Payne County DA Laura Austin Thomas’ office defended the deal as lawful, emphasizing “aggressive” therapy.
Critics blasted perceived favoritism. Butler’s father, Mack Butler, held prominent roles at OSU and Stillwater schools. One victim’s mother alleged school delays in separating the girls stemmed from influence. Assistant DA Debra Vincent reportedly vowed no leniency without full admission, but families felt betrayed.
Outrage went viral after bodycam release November 3-4, with millions viewing posts calling Butler a “monster” who’ll reoffend. State Rep. Justin “JJ” Humphrey slammed the deal: “The laws are there, but what do you do when they donβt follow them?” Protesters like Tori Grey decried no registry requirement.
Stillwater High warned students of unexcused absences for protesting, fueling silencing claims. Online sleuths and podcasts like “Just in the Nick of Crime” launched petitions to ban child predator plea deals.
Victims’ families spoke of lifelong trauma. One mother: “It seems inevitable” another will be hurt. The other victim’s doctor confirmed near-fatal injuries.
As of November 7, Butler remains free, barred from school property but virtually attending as a senior. Next hearing: December 8. Calls mount for investigations into Judge Worthington and DA practices.
This case highlights Oklahoma’s Youthful Offender Act debates: Rehabilitation vs. punishment for violent teens. Critics argue connections tipped scales; supporters say law mandates chances for minors.
Stillwater PD urges tips on related matters: (405) 372-3296. Protests continue; national attention grows via viral arrests and calls to “remember Jesse Mack Butler as a rapist.”
A community divided, victims scarred β Oklahoma demands answers.