In a surprise prime-time shake-up that’s already rippling across the media landscape, Fox News has officially named Sandra Smith as the new permanent co-host of The Five, replacing Jessica Tarlov in what insiders are calling a “strategic and game-changing move.”
The announcement came late Monday afternoon in a brief but pointed network press release, stating:
“Sandra Smith will join the 5 PM roundtable program, bringing her sharp reporting background and unmatched poise to the #1 cable news show in America.”
Tarlov, who has served as The Five’s liberal voice since 2021, will be moving to a “new on-air role” within the network — though specific details remain under wraps.
🧨 Behind-the-Scenes Buzz: Why Now?
Sources close to the network say the decision was “months in the making,” with top brass wanting to recalibrate the panel’s dynamic heading into the 2024 election cycle.
“This wasn’t personal — it was strategic,” one Fox insider told Mediaite.
“Sandra has proven herself across formats. She’s sharp, unflappable, and knows how to command airtime.”
Smith, best known for co-anchoring America Reports, brings a journalistic edge to the show — a contrast to the often fiery and emotionally charged tone of the current panel.
🎤 Smith’s Statement: Calm, But Powerful
While Sandra Smith has yet to make a formal on-air debut on The Five, she posted a brief message to X (formerly Twitter):
“Honored to join the table. Big conversations ahead. Let’s go.”
Fans immediately began speculating whether this shift signals a broader tone reset for the show, which continues to dominate the 5PM time slot despite occasional on-air tensions and viral clashes.
🤔 What About Jessica Tarlov?
Tarlov, a longtime Democratic strategist, has often been the lone progressive voice on the panel — a position that drew both fierce criticism and passionate support from viewers.
According to internal sources, she was informed last week and will transition into a new role that “better utilizes her analytical strengths.” Some speculate she may take on a solo contributor slot, while others believe a weekend format is in development around her.
“Jessica held her own in a tough room for years,” one producer noted.
“But this is Fox. The table always evolves.”
📊 What This Means for The Five
With Smith’s entry, Fox may be betting on a more reportorial, less combative approach — particularly as political coverage intensifies heading into 2025.
Industry analysts suggest the move is not just about ratings, but positioning — keeping The Five fresh, balanced, and responsive to audience shifts.
“It’s a big bet,” says media analyst Lauren Hicks.
“But Sandra Smith has credibility and composure. That could completely reframe how viewers engage with the format.”
📺 Bottom Line?
Sandra Smith is in. Jessica Tarlov is out. The Five just entered a new era.
And as one Fox exec put it bluntly:
“This isn’t the same show anymore — and that’s exactly the point.”