New York, NY โ May 30, 2025, 03:49 AM ET โ A leaked behind-the-scenes photo from Fox News featuring The Five co-hosts Greg Gutfeld and Dana Perino has set the internet ablaze, but itโs the mysterious element in the image that has fans and sleuths stumped. The candid snapshot, which surfaced on X late Thursday night, captures a rare off-air moment between the two starsโyet the #1 mystery at its center remains unsolved, fueling wild speculation and trending hashtags like #GutfeldPerinoMystery.
The photo, reportedly taken in the The Five green room on May 28, 2025, shows Gutfeld, 60, and Perino, 53, sharing a laugh over what appears to be a script or notes for an upcoming segment. Gutfeld, host of the late-night hit Gutfeld!, is pointing at something on the page, while Perino, a former White House Press Secretary, covers her mouth in mid-giggle. But the focal point of intrigue is a small, blurred object on the table between themโa cylindrical item that some fans swear resembles a baby bottle, while others insist itโs a rolled-up magazine or a prop for a skit.
The leak comes on the heels of both hostsโ recent personal milestones: Gutfeld welcomed his daughter Mira in December 2024 with wife Elena Moussa, and Perino became a mother to her own Mira via surrogacy around the same time. The possibility of a baby bottle has sparked theories tying the object to their new roles as parents. โAre Greg and Dana swapping parenting tips off-air? That bottle could be a clue!โ one X user posted. Another countered, โNo wayโitโs probably a prop for Gregโs next prank on Jesse Watters.โ Watters, their co-host, has been the target of Gutfeldโs on-air jabs, like the 2024 book ranking roast.
Adding to the mystery, the photoโs background includes a whiteboard with partially visible writing, including the words โratings boostโ and โyouth.โ This aligns with Fox Newsโ recent push to engage younger viewers, as The Five maintains its lead with 4.6 million viewers in Q1 2025, per Nielsen data, while Gutfeld! draws 2.3 million nightly. Some speculate the meeting was about a new segment, possibly inspired by Gutfeldโs Fox Nation show What Did I Miss?, which has gained traction with 1.8 million streams since its May 12 debut.
The image, credited to an anonymous crew member, went viral under #FoxNewsLeak, amassing over 500,000 views in hours. Fans have zoomed in, adjusted lighting, and even consulted photo experts, but the objectโs identity remains elusive. โItโs driving me nutsโwhat IS that thing?โ one user tweeted. Others noted the duoโs chemistry, with a post reading, โGreg and Dana laughing like old friendsโlove their vibe, but I need answers!โ Their camaraderie, often showcased through playful debates on The Five, contrasts with recent tensions, like Wattersโ reported walkout from a meeting with the pair on May 28.
Fox News has not commented on the leak, though a network insider told Deadline, โItโs just a candid momentโnothing more to read into.โ Yet, the unsolved mystery has only deepened fan engagement, with some suggesting the object might tie to an upcoming announcementโlike a joint project between Gutfeld and Perino, or a nod to their shared โMiraโ connection. As speculation swirls, this leaked photo has turned a fleeting behind-the-scenes moment into a digital detective challenge, proving once again that Fox Newsโ stars know how to keep audiences guessingโeven off the air.