‘We Were Never Friends’ – Shocking Betrayal in Wednesday Season 2 Splits Fandom in Half!
The eagerly awaited second season of Netflix’s Wednesday, starring Jenna Ortega as the iconic Wednesday Addams, has sent shockwaves through its fanbase with a dramatic betrayal that has sparked intense debate. The phrase “We Were Never Friends,” teased as a pivotal moment in Season 2, suggests a devastating rift between Wednesday and a key ally, possibly her werewolf roommate Enid Sinclair (Emma Myers), fracturing their hard-earned bond from Season 1. As ancestral secrets from the Addams family awaken a sinister force beneath Nevermore Academy, this betrayal has split the fandom, with heated discussions erupting across social media platforms like X and Reddit. This 1000-word article explores the betrayal, its implications, and the divided fan reactions, drawing on available teasers and Season 1 context.
The Setup: A Bond Forged in Season 1
Wednesday Season 1, released in November 2022, followed Wednesday Addams as she navigated Nevermore Academy, a gothic boarding school for outcasts in Jericho, Vermont. Initially aloof and fiercely independent, Wednesday clashed with her colorful roommate Enid, whose bubbly personality contrasted sharply with Wednesday’s deadpan demeanor. Despite their differences, the two developed a compelling friendship, culminating in a heartfelt hug after Enid’s werewolf transformation helped defeat the villainous Marilyn Thornhill/Laurel Gates (Christina Ricci) and the resurrected Joseph Crackstone. This moment, along with Wednesday’s growing ties to other students like Bianca Barclay (Joy Sunday) and Eugene Ottinger (Moosa Mostafa), marked her evolution from a loner to someone capable of trust.
The Season 1 finale left loose ends, including Tyler Galpin’s (Hunter Doohan) escape as a Hyde and an unseen stalker texting Wednesday, setting the stage for new conflicts. Showrunners Alfred Gough and Miles Millar have promised a “darker, more twisted” Season 2, leaning into horror and exploring the Addams family’s ancestral secrets. A sinister force beneath Nevermore, possibly tied to Goody Addams or the school’s founding, will drive the narrative, with the betrayal at its emotional core.
The Betrayal: “We Were Never Friends”
The phrase “We Were Never Friends” has become a lightning rod for speculation, with no official confirmation of the characters involved. However, fan theories, fueled by teasers and interviews, point to Enid as the most likely candidate for the betrayal. A Geeked Week 2024 featurette showed Enid and Wednesday working together, but Gough and Millar hinted at “new adversaries” and “complex relationships,” suggesting tension. Reddit user Secretgeordie446 proposed a dark theory that Enid could be Wednesday’s stalker, motivated by a desire to “be dark” to win Wednesday’s affection, though this would be a shocking departure from her loyal persona.
Another possibility involves Bianca, a siren with a complex history with Wednesday. In Season 1, Bianca sabotaged competitors during the Poe Cup but later allied with Wednesday against Crackstone. Her mother’s ties to the Morning Song cult could pull her into a scheme against Nevermore, leading to a confrontation where she declares, “We Were Never Friends.” Alternatively, the betrayal could involve a new character, such as Dr. Fairburn (Thandiwe Newton) or Capri (Billie Piper), introduced in Season 2 to disrupt Wednesday’s alliances.
The betrayal’s context likely ties to the sinister force beneath Nevermore. Teasers suggest hidden chambers and cursed relics related to the Addams family, possibly unleashed by Wednesday’s psychic visions or an outsider’s actions. If Enid or another friend is manipulated by this force—perhaps through Morning Song’s influence or a supernatural possession—their actions could shatter Wednesday’s trust, echoing Tyler’s deception in Season 1. Ortega’s comment to Variety in 2023 about ditching romance for horror indicates the focus will be on betrayal’s emotional weight rather than love triangles, amplifying the sting of this rift.
Fandom Split: Passionate Reactions
The betrayal has polarized fans, with X posts and Reddit threads revealing a fandom divided into two camps: those who embrace the dramatic twist and those who feel it betrays Season 1’s character arcs. Supporters argue that a betrayal fits Wednesday’s dark world, where trust is fragile. A Reddit user, DPGamez123, noted that Enid’s tears on the rooftop in Season 1 won Wednesday’s respect, but a betrayal could test her growth, forcing her to confront vulnerability. Others see it as a chance to explore Wednesday’s resilience, with one X post stating, “Wednesday thrives in chaos—let her face a friend’s knife!” Fans in this camp, often citing the show’s horror pivot, are excited for a gut-punch moment that challenges Wednesday’s stoic nature.
Opponents, however, feel the betrayal—especially if it involves Enid—undermines the heart of Season 1. Enid’s loyalty and their slow-burn friendship were highlights, with fans on X using #Wenclair (a portmanteau of Wednesday and Enid) to celebrate their bond, some even shipping them romantically. A Reddit thread with 487 votes lamented the potential loss of this dynamic, with users arguing that Enid turning against Wednesday feels “out of character” and risks alienating viewers who valued their growth. “Enid’s the sunshine to Wednesday’s storm,” one X user wrote. “Betraying her would break the show’s soul.” These fans fear the twist prioritizes shock over continuity, especially after the divisive Tyler reveal.
The debate has also sparked accusations of fan entitlement. Some X users criticize detractors for clinging to Season 1 dynamics, arguing that character evolution requires conflict. Others defend the right to dislike a twist that could “fridge” a beloved relationship for plot convenience. The split mirrors broader discussions about serialized storytelling, with fans citing shows like Euphoria and Yellowjackets for divisive betrayals that reshaped narratives.
Narrative Implications and New Cast
The betrayal will likely reshape Wednesday’s arc in Season 2, set to premiere in late 2025 or early 2026. If Enid is involved, it could parallel Wednesday’s Season 1 realization about Tyler, forcing her to question her judgment. Gough and Millar told The Hollywood Reporter that Season 2 will deepen Wednesday’s friendship with Enid while evolving her relationship with Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones), suggesting the betrayal may be temporary or redemptive. A supernatural manipulation, such as the sinister force controlling Enid, could allow for reconciliation, preserving their bond.
New cast members add complexity. Steve Buscemi as Nevermore’s new principal, Barry Dort, may navigate the fallout, while Joanna Lumley’s Grandmama could reveal Addams family secrets that contextualize the betrayal. Lady Gaga’s undisclosed role, possibly a villain tied to Morning Song, might orchestrate the rift, with Christopher Lloyd’s mysterious character (perhaps an Addams ancestor) complicating loyalties. The absence of Percy Hynes White (Xavier Thorpe), confirmed by Reddit posts, removes a key Season 1 ally, increasing the stakes for Wednesday’s remaining friendships.
Critical Perspective: Risk and Reward
The betrayal’s success hinges on execution. Season 1’s Tyler twist worked because it subverted high school tropes, revealing a trusted friend as a monster. However, repeating this with Enid risks redundancy unless the writing justifies her actions—perhaps through coercion or a moral dilemma tied to the Addams legacy. The show’s shift to Ireland for filming, with its misty gothic landscapes, will enhance the horror, but the emotional core must remain intact to avoid alienating fans. Ortega’s role as producer ensures Wednesday’s character stays true to her “spooky, independent” roots, which could ground the betrayal’s fallout.
Conclusion
The “We Were Never Friends” betrayal in Wednesday Season 2 has ignited a passionate divide, with fans split between embracing the dark twist and mourning the potential loss of a cherished friendship. Whether Enid, Bianca, or a new character delivers the blow, the rift ties to a sinister force beneath Nevermore, rooted in Addams family secrets. As Wednesday faces this emotional and supernatural chaos, the fandom’s debate reflects the show’s ability to provoke and engage. With a stellar cast and a horror-driven narrative, Season 2 promises to test Wednesday’s resilience, but it must balance shock with character integrity to heal the fandom’s fracture. The truth behind “We Were Never Friends” awaits, poised to redefine Nevermore’s legacy.