Greg Gutfeld Shares How His Second Pregnancy Started with “A Simple Prayer on New Year’s Eve” – Now He Believes in Miracles

Greg Gutfeld, the irreverent Fox News host of Gutfeld! and co-host of The Five, has never been one to shy away from bold statements or sharp humor. But in a rare and heartfelt moment, the 60-year-old comedian recently shared a deeply personal story that has left fans in awe: the journey to his second child began with “a simple prayer on New Year’s Eve.” This revelation, shared during a May 2025 episode of Gutfeld!, has sparked widespread discussion on X, with fans calling it a “miracle” and celebrating Gutfeld’s newfound belief in the power of faith. As he and his wife, Elena Moussa, prepare to welcome their second child, a girl, Gutfeld’s story is a testament to hope, love, and the unexpected twists of life. Let’s dive into this extraordinary moment and its impact.

A New Year’s Eve Prayer

Gutfeld’s announcement came during a lighthearted segment on Gutfeld!, where he typically delivers biting monologues on politics and culture. But this time, the tone shifted as he opened up about his family. With his signature grin, Gutfeld recounted how, on New Year’s Eve 2024, he and Elena, 42, shared a quiet moment at their $10.5 million New York City apartment. “We were sipping champagne, watching the ball drop, and Elena suggested we say a prayer for the year ahead,” he said. “I’m not exactly the churchgoing type, but I figured, why not? So we prayed for a healthy family, and maybe a little extra chaos to keep things interesting.” The audience laughed, but Gutfeld’s voice softened as he added, “Turns out, that prayer worked a little too well. Now we’re expecting baby number two, and I’m starting to believe in miracles.”

The story resonated deeply with fans, who flooded X with reactions. One user wrote, “Greg Gutfeld praying on New Year’s Eve and getting a baby girl? That’s a miracle I didn’t see coming!” Another posted, “From snarky host to miracle-believing dad—Greg’s living proof life’s full of surprises.” The revelation that a simple prayer led to their second pregnancy has struck a chord, especially given Gutfeld’s public persona as a skeptic and contrarian. His admission of newfound faith in miracles adds a layer of vulnerability that fans rarely see, making this moment all the more powerful.

The Miracle of Baby Number Two

Gutfeld and Elena welcomed their first child, a daughter named Mira, in November 2024, after a surprise announcement that followed his mysterious absence from Fox News. The couple kept Mira’s arrival private until December 10, 2024, when co-host Dana Perino shared the news on The Five, revealing that Mira was born with “Elena’s beautiful eyes and my rock-hard abs.” Now, less than a year later, the couple’s second pregnancy—a girl due later in 2025—has taken fans by surprise. Gutfeld’s claim that it began with a New Year’s Eve prayer has added a spiritual dimension to the story, with X users calling it a “New Year’s Eve miracle.”

The announcement came during a time of professional triumph for Gutfeld, whose show Gutfeld! achieved its highest-rated quarter in Q1 2025, averaging 3.3 million viewers and outpacing late-night rivals like Jimmy Fallon and Stephen Colbert. Yet, it’s his personal life that’s stealing the spotlight. Gutfeld shared that the pregnancy was unexpected, especially given his age and the couple’s focus on raising Mira. “I thought we were done at one,” he quipped on air. “But apparently, the universe—or someone upstairs—had other plans.” The reference to a “miracle” has sparked discussions on X about faith, family, and defying expectations, with one user posting, “Greg’s calling this a miracle, and I’m here for it. Proof you’re never too old for a new chapter.”

Fatherhood at 60: Challenges and Joys

Gutfeld’s journey into fatherhood at 60 has been a mix of humor and humility. After Mira’s birth, he took a 46-day paternity leave, later admitting on The Five that he was “terrible at everything” related to parenting, leaving most tasks to Elena, who he described as “pretty hands-on.” He jokingly confessed to spending much of his leave binge-watching Yellowstone, but also shared a profound shift in perspective, noting that a friend told him, “You can’t regret anything before her birth because it all led to her.” With a second child on the way, Gutfeld’s challenges are set to double, but so is his enthusiasm. “I’m already outnumbered,” he said on Gutfeld!. “Two girls and Elena? I’m gonna need a bigger apartment.”

The spiritual angle of the New Year’s Eve prayer adds depth to Gutfeld’s story. While he’s known for his libertarian-leaning, often irreverent commentary, his openness about faith has resonated with fans, especially those who share his conservative values. On X, one user wrote, “Greg talking about prayer and miracles is so refreshing. Faith can move mountains!” Another added, “From mocking liberals to believing in miracles—Greg’s dad era is iconic.” The announcement has also sparked conversations about later-in-life parenting, with Gutfeld’s story aligning with a cultural shift toward embracing family at any age.

The Bombshell: A Glimpse into Their Growing Family

The “bombshell” of Gutfeld’s second pregnancy lies not just in the prayer that started it, but in the joy and authenticity he brings to sharing it. Unlike many celebrities who stage elaborate announcements, Gutfeld’s reveal was classic him: humorous, heartfelt, and slightly chaotic. He teased that their second daughter might inherit Mira’s “set of lungs” and his own “questionable dance moves,” joking, “If she’s anything like Mira, she’ll be running the house by age two.” Fans on X have embraced the news, with posts like, “Greg’s got another mini-diva on the way? This family’s gonna be a riot!” and “New Year’s Eve prayer to miracle baby—Greg’s living a rom-com.”

The couple’s French bulldog, Gus, has also been part of the narrative, with Gutfeld humorously noting that Gus is “still adjusting” to Mira and might not be thrilled about another sibling. This blend of humor and relatability has endeared Gutfeld to fans, who see his parenting journey as a refreshing departure from his usual political jabs. The spiritual framing of the pregnancy as a “miracle” has also sparked discussions on X about the role of faith in modern life, with one user noting, “Greg’s prayer story reminds us miracles happen when you least expect them.”

Cultural Resonance and Fan Reactions

Gutfeld’s announcement comes at a time when stories of faith, family, and defying odds are trending. On X, users have connected his story to broader conversations about late-in-life parenthood and the power of small, intentional acts like prayer. One post read, “Greg and Elena’s New Year’s Eve prayer turning into a baby girl is the kind of hope we need in 2025.” Another user joked, “Greg’s proof miracles exist—and so is his ability to survive two kids at 60!” The announcement has also amplified Gutfeld’s appeal, blending his edgy humor with a softer, more reflective side.

The news has also sparked lighthearted speculation about the baby’s name. While Gutfeld revealed the second child is a girl, he’s kept the name under wraps, prompting X users to guess names like “Hope” or “Grace” to tie into the miracle theme. Gutfeld’s co-star Kat Timpf, who recently welcomed her own child, joined the fun on What Did I Miss?, joking, “If it’s not named after me, I’m staging a protest.” The camaraderie between Gutfeld and Timpf adds to the story’s charm, with fans appreciating their shared parenting banter.

Looking Ahead

As Gutfeld and Elena prepare for their second daughter, the “New Year’s Eve miracle” has become a touchstone for fans. Gutfeld’s belief in miracles, born from a simple prayer, has humanized the polarizing host, showing a side that transcends his on-air persona. On X, the excitement continues, with users posting, “Greg’s miracle baby is gonna be a firecracker like her dad!” and “From prayer to parenthood—Greg’s story is pure magic.” As Gutfeld navigates fatherhood, his fans eagerly await more glimpses into his growing family, proving that even the sharpest satirists can find miracles in the chaos of life.