Season 2 Turns Wednesday into the Villain? Fans Divided After Jaw-Dropping Plot Twist

Netflix’s Wednesday, starring Jenna Ortega as the iconic Wednesday Addams, has captivated audiences with its blend of gothic horror, mystery, and coming-of-age drama. As anticipation builds for Season 2, set to premiere in late 2025 or early 2026, a rumored plot twist has sent shockwaves through the fandom: Wednesday herself may become the villain. This jaw-dropping development, tied to ancestral Addams family secrets and a sinister force beneath Nevermore Academy, has sparked heated debates on platforms like X and Reddit, dividing fans between those who embrace the dark evolution and those who fear it betrays the character’s core. This 1000-word article explores the twist, its narrative roots, and the polarized fan reactions, drawing on teasers and Season 1 context.

The Context: Wednesday’s Season 1 Arc

In Season 1, released in November 2022, Wednesday Addams arrived at Nevermore Academy, a school for outcasts in Jericho, Vermont, after being expelled from multiple normie schools. Her sharp wit, psychic visions, and penchant for chaos defined her as an antihero, solving the mystery of a monster (revealed as Tyler Galpin, a Hyde) while thwarting a plot to resurrect the sadistic pilgrim Joseph Crackstone. Guided by her ancestor Goody Addams, Wednesday embraced her “raven” psychic abilities and forged bonds with peers like Enid Sinclair (Emma Myers), Bianca Barclay (Joy Sunday), and Eugene Ottinger (Moosa Mostafa), softening her loner persona.

The season ended with unresolved threats: Tyler’s escape, a stalker texting Wednesday, and the death of Principal Larissa Weems (Gwendoline Christie). Showrunners Alfred Gough and Miles Millar have promised a darker Season 2, leaning into horror and exploring the Addams family’s legacy. A Geeked Week 2024 teaser hinted at chaos, with ancestral secrets awakening a sinister force beneath Nevermore, setting the stage for the rumored twist that Wednesday could turn villainous.

The Plot Twist: Wednesday as the Villain

While Netflix has kept Season 2’s details under wraps, fan speculation and leaked rumors suggest a radical shift: Wednesday may embrace a villainous role, driven by the sinister force or her family’s dark history. The twist could stem from her psychic connection to Goody Addams, who killed Crackstone in the 1600s but may have sealed a malevolent entity beneath Nevermore, now unleashed. A Reddit thread from March 2025 posits that Wednesday’s visions might corrupt her, aligning her with this force—perhaps a demon or cursed Addams ancestor—making her an antagonist who threatens Nevermore.

Alternatively, the twist could involve Wednesday’s actions being perceived as villainous. For instance, she might unleash the force while investigating hidden chambers or relics, as teased by Gough and Millar, endangering her peers. A YouTube video from April 2025 speculates that Wednesday could join the Morning Song cult, introduced in Season 1 via Bianca’s mother, to gain power, betraying friends like Enid. The phrase “We Were Never Friends” from prior rumors might tie to this, with Wednesday rejecting allies in a descent into darkness.

Jenna Ortega, also an executive producer, told Variety in 2023 that Season 2 would ditch romance for horror, suggesting a focus on Wednesday’s darker impulses. Her Season 1 relish for chaos—torturing Tyler and nearly killing a bully—hints at a capacity for villainy, especially if pushed by supernatural or emotional triggers. The Addams family’s morally ambiguous ethos, seen in Gomez’s (Luis Guzmán) past murder and Fester’s (Fred Armisen) criminal antics, could justify Wednesday’s turn as a twisted extension of her heritage.

Fandom Divided: Embrace or Outrage?

The rumored twist has split fans into two camps, with X posts and Reddit discussions revealing passionate arguments. Supporters see Wednesday’s villain arc as a bold evolution, fitting her morally gray nature and the show’s horror pivot. A Reddit user, GothicRaven13, argued, “Wednesday’s always been one step from villainy—her torturing Tyler was peak Addams. Let her unleash hell!” Fans in this camp, citing her Season 1 line, “I act as if I don’t care if people hate me. Deep down, I secretly enjoy it,” view the twist as a natural progression, especially if tied to Goody’s legacy or a supernatural corruption. X posts praise the potential for Ortega’s chilling performance, with one user writing, “Jenna as a villain would slay. Give us unhinged Wednesday!”

Opponents, however, feel the twist betrays Wednesday’s Season 1 growth. Her friendships with Enid and Eugene, cemented by their fight against Crackstone, marked her as a reluctant hero. A Reddit thread with 623 upvotes decried the twist, with users arguing it risks alienating fans who rooted for her redemption. “Wednesday’s not a villain—she’s a protector of outcasts,” one X user posted, referencing her saving Nevermore. Critics fear the twist could mirror divisive arcs in shows like Game of Thrones, where Daenerys’ villain turn frustrated viewers. The #Wenclair fandom, celebrating Wednesday and Enid’s bond, is particularly vocal, with X posts like, “Turning Wednesday evil would gut her friendship with Enid. No thanks.”

The debate reflects broader tensions about character consistency versus narrative risk. Supporters argue that a temporary villain arc, perhaps resolved by Enid or Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones), could deepen Wednesday’s complexity. Detractors counter that it risks prioritizing shock over the show’s heart, especially after Season 1’s divisive Tyler reveal.

Narrative Stakes and New Characters

The twist raises high stakes for Season 2. If Wednesday becomes a villain, she could clash with allies like Enid, Bianca, or the Nightshade Society, now led by students. The sinister force might manipulate her psychic powers, forcing Morticia or Grandmama (Joanna Lumley) to intervene. New characters, including Steve Buscemi as Principal Barry Dort, Thandiwe Newton as Dr. Fairburn, Billie Piper as Capri, and Lady Gaga in a rumored villain role, could either exacerbate or counter Wednesday’s descent. Christopher Lloyd’s mysterious role—possibly an Addams ancestor—might reveal the force’s origins, tying to the hidden chambers teased in Black Star News.

The absence of Xavier Thorpe (Percy Hynes White), confirmed by Reddit leaks, and Weems’ death leaves Wednesday with fewer allies, amplifying the twist’s impact. If she betrays Enid, echoing the “We Were Never Friends” rumor, it could parallel Tyler’s deception, testing her ability to rebuild trust. Ireland’s gothic filming locations, with misty forests and castles, will enhance the horror, but the emotional fallout must resonate to justify the risk.

Critical Analysis: Can the Twist Work?

The twist’s success depends on execution. Season 1 balanced Wednesday’s darkness with growth, making her relatable despite her macabre tendencies. A villain arc could work if framed as a temporary corruption—perhaps the sinister force possesses her, mirroring Tyler’s Hyde transformation—or a morally ambiguous quest, like sacrificing Nevermore to defeat a greater evil. Ortega’s nuanced performance and producer role ensure Wednesday’s core remains intact, but the writing must avoid alienating fans who cherish her heroism.

Comparisons to Yellowjackets, where characters blur hero-villain lines, suggest Wednesday could pull it off with strong character motivation. A redemptive arc, with Enid or Morticia pulling Wednesday back, could satisfy both camps, preserving her antihero status. However, repeating Season 1’s betrayal formula risks redundancy, requiring fresh stakes tied to the Addams legacy.

Conclusion

The rumored twist of Wednesday turning villain in Season 2 has ignited a fierce fandom divide, with fans split between excitement for a darker arc and concern for her heroic roots. Tied to ancestral secrets and a sinister force beneath Nevermore, the twist promises chaos, amplified by a stellar cast and horror-driven narrative. Whether Wednesday’s villainy is a supernatural corruption or a deliberate choice, it challenges her bonds and legacy, testing her resilience. As debates rage on X and Reddit, Wednesday Season 2 must balance shock with character integrity to unite its fractured fandom, proving that even in darkness, Wednesday Addams remains unforgettable.