On March 17, 2025, Kayleigh McEnany, former White House Press Secretary and co-host of Fox News’ Outnumbered, announced her third pregnancy live on air, captivating viewers with her joyful revelation. However, in a surprising twist, McEnany later shared that she had kept the pregnancy under wraps from her Fox News colleagues for weeks, only for one perceptive co-host to pick up on subtle clues and guess the news first. The announcement, coupled with the story of her secrecy and the co-host’s intuition, sparked widespread buzz among fans and media outlets. This 1000-word article delves into the details of McEnany’s hidden pregnancy, the co-host who figured it out, the emotional announcement, and the faith-driven context that shaped her journey.
A Secret Kept from Fox News
During the Outnumbered broadcast, McEnany, glowing in a bright pink blazer paired with blue pumps, teased a “big announcement” before revealing that she and her husband, Sean Gilmartin, a retired MLB pitcher, are expecting their third child in June 2025. The baby will join their daughter Blake, 5, and son Nash, 2, expanding their family to five. Her co-hosts, including Emily Compagno and Harris Faulkner, erupted in cheers, with Compagno exclaiming, “We love you so much, congratulations to all now five of you!” But in a post-show interview with People magazine, McEnany disclosed that she had concealed her pregnancy from her Fox News team for nearly two months, navigating early pregnancy symptoms while maintaining her on-air duties.
“I was about six weeks along when I started feeling the symptoms, but I didn’t want to say anything until we were past the first trimester,” McEnany explained. She described wearing looser clothing and avoiding certain foods on set to mask morning sickness, all while keeping up her rigorous schedule on Outnumbered and occasional fill-in roles on The Five and Fox & Friends. The secrecy, she admitted, was challenging, especially given the close-knit dynamic among the Outnumbered panel, who often share personal anecdotes on air. “I thought I was pulling it off, but one person saw right through me,” she said with a laugh.
The Co-Host Who Figured It Out First
The co-host who cracked McEnany’s secret was Emily Compagno, whose keen observation skills led to a private moment of realization. McEnany recounted that around week eight, Compagno pulled her aside after a taping and gently asked, “Are you okay? You seem… different.” McEnany, caught off guard, initially deflected but confessed when Compagno pressed further, noting that she’d noticed McEnany skipping coffee—a staple for the high-energy host—and opting for ginger ale. “Emily’s like a detective,” McEnany told People. “She hugged me and promised to keep it quiet until I was ready.” Compagno’s intuition was no surprise to fans, as the former attorney and NFL cheerleader is known for her sharp wit and empathetic nature on Outnumbered.
Compagno later confirmed the story on air, joking, “I knew something was up when Kayleigh passed on her usual latte!” The lighthearted exchange underscored the camaraderie among the Outnumbered hosts, with Faulkner adding, “Emily’s got a sixth sense for these things.” Fans on X celebrated Compagno’s perceptiveness, with one user posting, “Emily Compagno calling it first is so on-brand! Love the sisterhood on Outnumbered.” The revelation added a layer of warmth to the announcement, highlighting the supportive environment at Fox News.
The Emotional On-Air Reveal
When McEnany finally shared her pregnancy on Outnumbered, the segment was a blend of joy, faith, and relatability. Holding up a framed ultrasound photo, she shared, “This is from recently, so you can see the baby. It’s very sweet.” She noted that her family frames all their children’s sonograms, a tradition reflecting her reverence for life. Her daughter Blake’s excitement was a highlight, as McEnany recounted, “She runs up and holds my stomach and says, ‘Let me kiss the baby.’” The moment resonated with viewers, many of whom flooded X with messages like, “Kayleigh’s love for her kids is so beautiful.”
McEnany’s faith, a cornerstone of her public persona, infused the announcement with depth. Quoting Jeremiah 1:5—“Before I formed you in the womb, I knew you”—and Luke 12:7, she emphasized God’s intimate care for her unborn child and all people. “It’s not just a message about my baby, it’s a message about all of you,” she told the audience, prompting emotional responses online. Her pink blazer, she clarified, was not a gender hint, pointing to her blue pumps and a blue pacifier on a congratulatory graphic. “We’ll do a gender reveal here,” she promised, sparking anticipation for future segments.
A Journey Marked by Resilience
McEnany’s ability to keep her pregnancy secret while managing a high-profile role reflects her resilience, a trait honed through personal and professional trials. Born in Tampa, Florida, she graduated from Georgetown University and Harvard Law School before rising through media and politics. As White House Press Secretary from April 2020 to January 2021, she navigated intense scrutiny, earning both praise and criticism for her staunch defense of the Trump administration. Since joining Fox News in 2021, she has become a beloved figure on Outnumbered, blending sharp commentary with personal vulnerability.
Her personal life has been shaped by health challenges, including a 2018 preventative double mastectomy after testing positive for the BRCA2 gene mutation, which carries an 84% breast cancer risk. Supported by Gilmartin, whom she married in 2017, and a call from then-President Trump during recovery, she emerged stronger, later detailing the experience in her 2021 book, For Such a Time as This. Fertility struggles also marked her journey, with months of negative tests before conceiving Nash, overcome through prayer, as she shared in a 2023 CBN News interview. These experiences contextualize her careful approach to her third pregnancy, as she waited until the 12-week mark to share the news publicly.
Fan Reactions and Future Anticipation
The story of McEnany’s hidden pregnancy and Compagno’s sleuthing captivated fans, who took to X to share their excitement. Posts like “Kayleigh keeping it secret for weeks is so relatable, but Emily figuring it out is next-level!” reflected the public’s affection for both hosts. Others praised McEnany’s faith-driven announcement, with one user writing, “Her quoting Jeremiah 1:5 gave me chills. What a testimony.” The promise of a gender reveal kept the buzz alive, with McEnany teasing further updates on social media and Outnumbered.
The announcement also highlighted McEnany’s ability to connect with her audience, blending her roles as a public figure, mother, and woman of faith. As she prepares for her third child, her journey—from concealing her pregnancy to sharing it with the world—resonates as a story of joy, trust, and community.